| Spring 2024 | The Falcon, Micklegate | The Grapes, Slingsby |
| Winter 2023 | The Black Horse, Monkgate | The Wadkin Arms, Osgodby |
| Autumn 2023 | The Waggon and Horses, Lawrence Street | The White Bear Inn, Stillington |
| Summer 2023 | The Fox, Holgate Road | The Feversham Arms, Farndale |
| Spring 2023 | The Last Drop, Colliergate | The Lord Nelson, Nether Poppleton |
| Winter 2022 | The Winning Post, Bishopthorpe Road | The Thompsons Arms, Flaxton |
| Autumn 2022 | The Phoenix Inn, George Street | The Fleece Inn, Bishop Wilton |
| Summer 2022 | The Snickleway Inn, Goodramgate | The Woodman Inn, Bishopthorpe |
| Spring 2022 | The Minster Inn, Marygate | The Doghouse, Selby |
| Winter 2021 | The Ackhorne, St Martin's Lane | The Bay Horse, Burythorpe |
| Autumn 2021 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 |
| Summer 2021 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 |
| Spring 2021 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 |
| Winter 2020 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 |
| Autumn 2020 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 |
| Summer 2020 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 |
| Spring 2020 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 | Not awarded due to Covid-19 |
| Winter 2019 | The Shambles Tavern, Shambles | The Marcia Inn, Bishopthorpe |
| Autumn 2019 | The Knavesmire Hotel, Albermarle Road | The Coach House Inn, Rosedale |
| Summer 2019 | The Volunteer Arms, Watson Street | The Doghouse, Selby |
| Spring 2019 | The House of the Trembling Madness, Lendal | The Market Tap, Pocklington |
| Winter 2018 | The Fox, Holgate Road | The Three Hares Inn, Bilbrough |
| Autumn 2018 | The Gillygate, Gillygate | The Golden Lion, Helperby |
| Summer 2018 | The Wellington Inn, Alma Terrace | The New Inn, Cliffe |
| Spring 2018 | Three Legged Mare, High Petergate | The Lion Inn, Blakey Ridge |
| Winter 2017 | The Swan, Clementhorpe | The Blacksmiths Arms, Lastingham |
| Autumn 2017 | The Ackhorne, St Martin's Lane | The Hare and Hounds, Holme-on-Spalding Moor |
| Summer 2017 | Slip Inn | George & Dragon, West Haddlesey |
| Spring 2017 | Brew York | Bay Horse, Burythorpe |
| Winter 2016 | Blue Bell, York | Moors Inn, Appleton le Moors |
| Autumn 2016 | Eagle & Child, York | Lord Collingwood, Upper Poppleton |
| Summer 2016 | Knavesmire, York | Ebor, Bishopthorpe |
| Spring 2016 | Walmgate Alehouse | Mended Drum, Huby |
| Winter 2015 | Falcon Tap, York | George Hotel, Easingwold |
| Autumn 2015 | House of Trembling Madness, York | Fenton Flyer, Church Fenton |
| Summer 2015 | Golden Ball, York | Dawnay Arms, Shipton by Beningborough |
| Spring 2015 | Unicorn, Selby | Crown & Cushion, Welburn |
| Winter 2014 | Phoenix, York | Marcia Inn, Bishopthorpe |
| Autumn 2014 | Rook & Gaskill, York | Whelans, Asselby |
| Summer 2014 | Volunteer Arms, York | Jolly Farmers, Leavening |
| Spring 2014 | Pitchside Bar, York | Gait Inn, Millington |
| Winter 2013 | Royal Oak, York | White Bear, Stillington |
| Autumn 2013 | Snickleway Inn, York | Greyhound, Saxton |
| Summer 2013 | Old Ebor, York | Wombwell Arms, Wass |
| Spring 2013 | Habit, York | Fenton Flyer, Church Fenton |
| Winter 2012 | York Tap, York | New Inn, Cliffe
Blacksmiths Arms, Lastingham |
| Autumn 2012 | Phoenix, York | Old Black Bull, Raskelf |
| Summer 2012 | Maltings, York | Wadkin Arms, Osgodby |
| Spring 2012 | Volunteer Arms, York | Cross Keys, Thixendale |
| Winter 2011 | Fulford Arms, York | Kings Head, Barmby on the Marsh |
| Autumn 2011 | Fox, York | Forresters Arms, Kilburn |
| Summer 2011 | Lamb & Lion, York | Fauconberg Arms, Coxwold |
| Spring 2011 | Old White Swan, York | Moors Inn, Appleton-le-Moors |
| Winter 2010 | Slip Inn, York | St Vincent Arms, Sutton upon Derwent |
| Autumn 2010 | Phoenix, York | Boot & Shoe, Barkston Ash |
| Summer 2010 | Victoria, York | White Bear, Stillington |
| Spring 2010 | Rook & Gaskill, York | Lord Collingwood, Poppleton |
| Winter 2009 | Minster Inn, York | Greyhound, Riccall |
| Autumn 2009 | Waggon & Horses, York | Bay Horse Inn, Terrington |
| Summer 2009 | Punch Bowl, Blossom Street, York | Boot & Shoe, Ellerton |
| Spring 2009 | Judges Lodging, York | Gait, Millington |
| Winter 2008 | Guy Fawkes, York | Wadkin Arms, Osgodby |
| Autumn 2008 | Three-Legged Mare, York | Cross Keys, |
| Summer 2008 | Swan, York | Forresters Arms, Kilburn |
| Spring 2008 | Lysander Arms, York | George & Dragon, West Haddlesey |
| Winter 2007 | George & Dragon, Kirkbymoorside | Barnes Wallis, Howden Station |
| Autumn 2007 | Jackdaw, Tadcaster | Farmers Arms, Fridaythorpe |
| Summer 2007 | Yorkshire Terrier, York | Crown & Cushion, Welburn |
| Spring 2007 | Brigantes, York | Wheatsheaf, Burn |
| Winter 2006 | Rook & Gaskill, York | Blacksmiths Arms, Lastingham |
| Autumn 2006 | Kings Head, Kirkbymoorside | Jolly Farmers, Leavening |
| Summer 2006 | Blue Bell, York | Ferry Boat Inn, Thorganby |
| Spring 2006 | Maltings, York | Fleece, Bishop Wilton |
| Winter 2005 | Ackhorne, York | Three Hares, Bilbrough |
| Autumn 2005 | Phoenix, York | Wombwell Arms, Wass |
| Summer 2005 | Golden Lion, York | New Inn, Cropton |
| Spring 2005 | Rose & Crown, York | St. Vincent Arms, Sutton upon Derwent |
| Winter 2004 | Tap & Spile, York | White Swan, Deighton |
| Autumn 2004 | Golden Slipper, York | Blacksmith’s, Lastingham |
| Summer 2004 | Minster Inn, York | Blacksmith’s Arms, Newton on Ouse |
| Spring 2004 | Royal Oak, Tadcaster | Wheatsheaf, Burn |
| Winter 2003 | Rook & Gaskill, York | Ferryboat, Thorganby |
| Autumn 2003 | George, Easingwold, York | Malt Shovel, Oswaldkirk |
| Summer 2003 | Golden Ball, York | Jug & Bottle, Bubwith |
| Spring 2003 | Olde Starre Inn, York | Agar Arms, Warthill |
| Winter 2002 | Swan, York | Greyhound, Riccall |
| Autumn 2002 | Tap & Spile, York | Spotted Ox, Tockwith |
| Summer 2002 | Last Drop Inn, York | Appletree Inn, Marton |
| Spring 2002 | Golden Lion, York | Alice Hawthorn, Nun Monkton |
| Winter 2001 | Blue Bell, York | Half Moon, Helperby |
| Autumn 2001 | Minster Inn, York | St. Vincent Arms, Sutton upon Derwent |
| Summer 2001 | Phoenix, York | Crown, Hemingbrough |
| Spring 2001 | Angel & White Horse, Tadcaster | Stone Trough, Kirkham Abbey |
| Winter 2000 | Three Cranes, York | Grey Horse, Elvington |
| Autumn 2000 | Wellington Inn, York | Barnes Wallis, Howden Station |
| Summer 2000 | Carlton Tavern, Acomb, York | Three Hares, Bilbrough |
| Spring 2000 | Victoria, York | Alice Hawthorn, Nun Monkton |
| Winter 1999 | Ackhorne, York | Jug, Chapel Haddlesey |
| Autumn 1999 | Saddle, Fulford, York | Kings Arms, North Duffield |
| Summer 1999 | Maltings, York | Greyhound, Saxton |
| Spring 1999 | Tap & Spile, York | Wheatsheaf, Burn |
| Winter 1998 | Swan, York | Ferryboat, Thorganby |
| Autumn 1998 | Sun, Acomb, York | Ferry Inn, Cawood |
| Summer 1998 | Phalanx & Firkin, York | Plough, Burton Salmon |
| Spring 1998 | Royal Oak, Selby | Cross Keys, |
| Winter 1997 | Rose & Crown, York | Spotted Ox, Tockwith |
| Autumn 1997 | Golden Ball, York | White Swan, Kirkbymoorside |
| Summer 1997 | Minster Inn, York | Barnes Wallis, Howden Station |
| Spring 1997 | Golden Lion, York | Alice Hawthorn, Nun Monkton |
| Winter 1996 | Cricketers, Selby | Station, Easingwold |
| Autumn 1996 | Saddle, Fulford, York | Ulleskelf Arms, Ulleskelf |
| Summer 1996 | Masons Arms, York | Jolly Farmers, Leavening |
| Spring 1996 | Royal Oak, York | St. Vincent Arms, Sutton upon Derwent |
| Winter 1995 | Albion Vaults, Selby | Barnes Wallis, Howden Station |
| Autumn 1995 | Ackhorne, York | New Inn, Cropton |
| Summer 1995 | Lighthorseman, York | Kings Arms, North Duffield |
| Spring 1995 | Brewers Arms, York | Jolly Farmers, Leavening |
| Winter 1994 | Maltings, York | Hemingbrough Hall Hotel |
| Autumn 1994 | Blue Bell, York | Golden Lion, Helperby |
| Summer 1994 | Wellington Inn, York | New Inn, Cropton |
| Spring 1994 | York Beer Shop, York | Alice Hawthorn, Nun Monkton |
| Winter 1993 | Ackhorne, York | Ferry Inn, Cawood |
| Autumn 1993 | Maltings, York | Station, Easingwold |
| Summer 1993 | Clarence Gardens Hotel, York | Wombwell Arms, Wass |
| Spring 1993 | John Bull, York | Golden Lion, Helperby |
